Analyzing the Biographical Methods in Developing Prospective Teachers to Measure the Mental States of the Students
This study aims to investigate the research work results, which prove the possibility of using biographical analysis techniques to develop prospective teachers to measure the mental states of the students. The biographical strategy and procedures for the examination of mental states are examined at the interdisciplinary level. It has been revealed that biography describes a philosophy of this phenomenon through life's retrospective prism and as a response that shows an individual's outlook on their mental features in numerous social circumstances. To interpret that, a pedagogical and psychological study is conducted—this study had no analog theory and use of subjective and pedagogical science. The mentioned study has been conducted in 4 levels: organizational stage-this stage is completed to demonstrate the technical and methodological interpretation of experimental work; ascertaining step-the predictive implies to discover the willingness levels of prospective teachers to employ the methods of biographical analysis in examining the students' mental states have been investigated; formative step–it indicates the author's methodology for promoting the prospective teachers' knowledge, skills, talents to use biographical methods in analyzing the students' mental states as well as their correction; control step–this stage illustrates the outcomes of psychological and pedagogical experiment. Based on the results acquired, it can be inferred that the author's teaching approaches' effectiveness is to apply biographical methods to develop prospective teachers to measure and resolve students' mental states. Furthermore, this matter helps manifest that biographical strategies and the fundamental psychological are excellent in diagnosing personality.
Mental states, Biographical methods, Methods of mental diagnostics, Future teachers, Secondary school students
A habit is an automatically done behavior that could be a repetitive and monotonous . Harmful habits are the popular issue of pediatricians, which influences the quality of life. Bad habits are a frequent behavior inside the mouth. They include nonnutritive sucking (of the thumb, pacifier, and lips) and the habit of nails biting, as well as the grinding of teeth in addition to the mouth breathing. If the oral habits are practiced at a higher level, and for a longer duration, the muscular imbalance in the growing dental structures will lead to malocclusion, deformation of the face and slackening of speech [2, 3]. Finger sucking is very normal and most common bad oral habits in children. It can be defined as the placement of the finger in varying depths into the oral cavity . On the other hand, nail biting is “putting one or more fingers in the mouth and biting on nail with teeth” . Recurring habits are more common during the childhood, and most of them start and end on their own . In fact, due to a lack of awareness and knowledge to the harmful effects of bad oral habits, some children may continue these habits into their teenage years . The use of these habits may have some advantages to the child in that sucking is most often noticed when a child is worry, unsafe, tense or surrounded by strangers. It also can make sleep easy, it keeps the baby and toddler calm and relaxed when the child separated from his family . However, bad oral habits (such as sucking fingers and nails biting) may have adverse effects. They may lead to distortion to the harmony of the face and the oral cavity by destroying the structure of the mouth leading to disturbances and imbalance in the development of the jaw, poor dental position and malocclusion as well as it may be a cause of tooth decay and gum disease by altering the oral microflora. Meanwhile, they may lead to spreading of many infectious diseases, respiratory disorder, speech difficulty, imbalance in the muscles, and psychological problems [9-12]. The severity of these adverse effects will depend on the nature, appearance, and duration of the habit .
This study was done as an attempt to link the bad oral habits with the oral health among children in Al Hilla city.
Materials and Methods
After the submission and the revision of the study protocol, approval was obtained from the Scientific and the Ethical Committee at the Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry Department/ College of Dentistry/ University of Baghdad, Iraq. An approval was obtained from the Directorate of General Education in Al Hilla city to perform the study at the primary schools without any hindrances. In this study, declaration of Helsinki had been followed, where complete information was given to the parents/guardians of each child (concerning the study design, aims and the predictable benefits of the study) before their inclusion in the study. This was done after getting a signed written consent, ensuring them that they have the right to withdraw (if they wanted) from this study at any time they want.
In this study, selection of the sample was done by using a multi-stage cluster random sampling method by which the first stage was the enrollment of 500 elementary school students within the selected age (6-10 years). They were belonged to nine elementary schools that were randomly selected as they belonged to different geographical areas in the center of Hialla city (the capital of Iraq's Babylon Governorate), which is located some 100 km to the south of Baghdad. In the second stage, information through questioners (related to the demographic personal information for each student included in this study was collected. The questionnaires included the child birthday date, the gender, feeding type, presence of the sucking habit (thumb sucking and nail-biting habits) and duration of the sucking habit. Out of 500 children who got the questionnaire, only 436 return them (they were medically fit and healthy). The exclusion criteria of the sample from the present study were: (1) Incomplete filled questionnaire . (2) Children whose parents refused their participation in the study. (3) If the child aged was over 10 years old or less than 6 years old. (4) If the child treated by an orthodontic device at the time of the study or previously. (5) Children with congenital or acquired deformity (e.g., syndromic and cleft). (6) Presence of bad oral habits other than thumb sucking and nail biting.
Thumb Sucking: The bad habit was checked first by asking the parents by a special designed questionnaire concerning which finger the child was sucked and the way by which it was sucked. The next step was to examine the thumb finger to find if there was a callus formation, cleaner fingernail, or reddish color , or acquired rotation, which is the most frequent deformation . Only those children who sucked their thumb were included in this study.
Nail biting: This habit was checked according to Odenrick et al.  by asking whether the students bite their nail often or in frequently. They were also asked whether it was possible to see from their nails that they were nail biters.
Clinical examination for the presence of dental caries was done according to WHO (1997) by using a plan mouth mirror and CPI explorer after drying the teeth with a cotton roll. A systemic approach was adopted for the examination of the dental caries proceeding in an ordered way from one tooth or tooth space to the adjacent tooth or tooth space starting from upper right molar ending with the lower right molar .
Data analysis was performed by using Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS Software) version 21. Descriptive (mean, standard error (SE), frequency and percentage) and inferential statistics had been utilized. The level of significance was set at 5%.
In this study, the study sample composed of 200 students (100 students with bad oral habits (thumb sucking and nail biting) and 100 students without any sucking habits matching the age and gender of the study group), as shown in Table 1. Regarding the age of the sample, thumb sucking habit tended to decrease with increasing the age of the students. However, concerning the gender variable of the total sample, girls sucked their thumb more than boys did (56%, 44% respectively). On the contrary, boys were tended to bite their nails more than girls did (54%, 46% respectively). All of the students with bad oral habits had dental caries (100%) than the students without the bad habits (97%), (Table 2).
Table 1: Examples of question-provisions from the “Questionnaire to determine the levels of competence in the use of methods of biographical analysis in the study of students’ mental states”
|1||The value of pedagogical biography in the training of future teachers||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|2||Significance of studying pedagogical states of students for the organization of educational work||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|3||Personal possession of theoretical knowledge about the pedagogical state of students||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|4||Personal mastery of skills and abilities to use methods of studying the pedagogical states of students||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|5||Personal knowledge of methods and technologies of organization of educational work in secondary school||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|6||Personal knowledge of biographical analysis methods||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|7||Personal ability to use methods of biographical analysis in practice||5,4,3,2,1,0|
|8||Readiness for professional activity in secondary school||5,4,3,2,1,0|
Table 2: Sample of "Chronological table of mental states"
|Chronology||Event, fact||Subjective state||Characteristic,
|Estimation of the period|
|July 2019||I began the master's program||Intense feelings because, on the one hand, I needed to study; on the other hand, I prepared to operate as a teacher||I was thrilled and inspired since the desire to maintain her studies was actualized. Simultaneously, she was confused due to the delay of work at school||During the initial year, she was unstable since she was not certain whether she had made the right choice|
Results in Table 3 showed that, concerning caries experience for the permanent teeth, there was a highly significant difference between the students with bad oral habits and those without any sucking habits. This was found to be for all the components of the index (DS, MS, FS), as well as for total DMFS by which students with bad oral habits showed higher mean than those without any sucking habits. This was true for the primary dentition also.
Table 3: The outcomes of diagnostics of the readiness levels of EG members to utilize the biographical analysis techniques in studying students' mental states, acquired at the ascertaining ("before") and control ("after") stages of the experiment (in%).
|Levels / criteria||Cognitive criteria||Activity criteria|
|High||-||26,7 %||-||40 %|
|Medium||33,3 %||60 %||57,4 %||53,3 %|
|Low||66,7 %||13,3 %||36,4 %||6,7 %|
Oral habits have been the topic of interest to the dentists, especially the pediatric dentists. Sample selection was done randomly to be representative of 6-10 years in Hilla city. The distribution of thumb sucking habits found to be more in the younger children than the older children did (Table 1). This agreed with other studies [19-21], this might be due to that as the child becomes older, his/her need to suck decrease and the child will likely give up the habit by his own way, while other children will be motivated to stop the habit by their parents. This can be illustrated relying on the facts provided by the psychoanalytic theory, which states that when children grow up, they are prone to take off some habits and sustaining others . Regarding gender, it was found that girls tended to suck their thumbs more frequently than boys did, and this could be since girls are more sensitive than boys [23-25].
Caries experience was demonstrated by DMFT index for the permanent teeth and dmft index for the primary teeth, which are well-accepted measure for caries experience throughout the world. In the present study, all the students among the group with bad oral habits were affected by dental caries (100%) (Table 2). Meanwhile, for the permanent teeth, the mean of the decayed surfaces among the group with bad oral habits was the higher component of the DMFS index. In the same manner, incidence of dental caries for the primary teeth that represented by dmfs was higher among the group with bad oral habits (8.380) than it was among the group without any sucking habit which was (3.140) (Table 3). For the primary teeth, the higher mean of the dmfs components was related to the decayed surfaces as well as to the missing surfaces among the group with bad oral habits (4.320, 3.070 respectively) compared to the group without any sucking habits (1.970, 0.630 respectively). Therefore, it was observed that bad oral habits increased the odds of having dental caries among children, this was in accordance with the results of other studies [26,27]. Presence of the thumb or the nail inside the mouth may act as a foreign body that aid in carrying of various types of microorganisms from the surrounding environment to the oral cavity. This may lead to altering the oral ecosystem, which in turn may lead to increasing the chance of affecting by dental caries.
Bad oral habits were more prevalent among girls as well as the younger age students and concerning dental caries, the group with the bad oral habits exhibits higher mean of both DMFS and dmfs with a higher statistically significant difference between the two groups. Therefore, one of the important conclusions related to the present study is that there is no doubt that bad oral habit can act as an important predisposing factor aid in increasing the severity of dental caries. So, stopping the bad oral habits can be considered as an important first step for the prevention of dental and oral disease.
- Allport GW. The use of personal documents in psychological science. Socіal Scienct Research Councsl. New York. 1942.
- Anan'ev BG. A man as a subject for cognition [in Russian]. Leningrad: University of Leningrad Publishing House. 1968.
- Ahmerov RA. Biographical personality crises [in Russian]. Abstract of the candidate dissertation. Moskоv. 1984.
- Behterev VM. Suggestion and education. Problems of human development and upbringing [in Russian]. Voronezh.
- (2007) Big Encyclopedia of Psychological Tests [in Russian]. Moskоv. 1997.
- Burlachuk LF, Korzhova, EJu. Psychologyoflifesituations [in Russian]. Moskоv. 1998.
- Vladimirova NM. Possibilitiesofpsychographicstudyofstudents [in Russian]. Problems of improving academic performance and reducing dropout rates. Leningrad 1983:109-113.
- Buhler Ch. Basic theoretical concepts of humanistic psychology. American Psychologist 1971;26(4):378-386.
- Conway JR, Coll MP, Cuve НС, Koletsi S, Bronitt N, Catmur K, Bird G. Understanding How Minds Vary Relates to Skill in Inferring Mental States, Personality, and Intelligence. J Exp Psychol Gen 2019;149(6):1032-1047. https://doi.org/ 10.1037/xge0000704
- Gol'dberg II. Howtodecrypthandwriting. Graphology step by step [in Russian]. Moskоv. 2008.
- Dostoyevskyy FM. Тhe village of Stepanchikogo and its inhabitants in Russian]. Full composition of writings in 30 volumes. Vol. 18. Leningrad: Science 1972;5-168.
- Kovalev VI. Psychological features of the personal organization of life time [in Russian]. Abstract of the candidate dissertation. Moskоv. 1979.
- Goldstein I. Intersubjective Properties by Which We Specify Pain, Pleasure, and Other Kinds of Mental States. Philosophy2000;75:89-104. https://doi.org/ 10.1017/s0031819100000073.
- Goodwin J. Research in Psychology Methods and Design. Sixth Edition. Western Carolina University. 2010.
- Golovaha EI, Kronik AA. Psychologicalpersonalitytime [in Russian]. Kyiv. 1984.
- Dikaja LG. Mental self-regulation of a person’s functional state [in Russian]. Moskоv. 2003.
- Il'in EP. Psychophysiology of human conditions [in Russian]. St. Petersburg. 2005.
- Kirshbaum JeI, Eremeeva AI. Mental states [in Russian]. Vladivostok. 1990.
- Loginova NA. Biographical method of research and personality correction [in Russian]. Almaty. 2001.
- Menzhulіn VІ. Biographicalapproachinhistoricalandphilosophicalcognition [in Ukrainian]. Kyiv. 2010.
- Mjasishhev VN. Relationshippsychology [in Russian]. Moskov. 1995.
- Piccinini G. Functionalism, Computationalism, & Mental States. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 2004;35(4):811–833. https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.shpsa..02.003.
- Putnam H. The nature of mental states/ Art, Mind, and Religion. Pittsburgh University Press. Retrieved from: philpapers.org › rec › PUTTNO. 1967.
- Rybnikov NA. Psychology and the study of biographies. Psychology [in Russian] 1929;11(2):4-29.
- Pevneva AN. Mentalstatesofpersonality [in Russian]. Gomel'. 2011.
- Psychology Workshop. [in Russian]. Pod red. A.O. Prohorova. St. Petersburg. 2004.
- Prohorov AO. Self-regulation of mental states: phenomenology, mechanisms, patterns[in Russian]. Moskov. 2005.
- Psychologyofconditions: anthology [in Russian]. Order T.N. Vasilieva and others. St. Petersburg. 2004.
- Sypachevskaja Ju. Praktikum po urovnjam slushanija. 2011. Retrieved from: http://vk.com/topic-36238584_26047576.
- Rokeach M. The Nature of Human Values. New York: The Free Press. Retrievd from: academic.oup.com › article. 1973.
- Schwartz SH. An Overview of the Schwartz Theory of Basic Values. Online Readings in Psychology and Culture 2012;2(1). https://doi.org/10.9707/2307-0919.1116.
- Hanley J. Lifespring: getting yourself from where you are to where you want to be. NY.: Simon and Schuster. 1989.
- Frojd Z. Introduction to psychoanalysis [in Ukrainian]. Kyiv. 2015.
- Weintraub, R. (1987). Unconscious Mental States. The Philosophical Quarterly, 37(149), 423–432. https://doi.org/10.2307/2219572. JSTOR 2219572.
2Mukachevo State University, Mukachevo, Ukraine
3Kherson State University, Kherson, Ukraine
4Rivne Regional Institute of Postgraduate Pedagogical Education, Rivne, Ukraine
5Horbachevsky Ternopil State Medical University, Ternopil, Ukraine
Citation: Boris Savchuk, Iryna Rozman, Nina Slyusarenko, Hryhorii Pustovit, Nataliia Blahun, Inna Feltsan, Mariia Cherepania, Nadiya Fedchyshyn, Halyna Bilavych, Analyzing the Biographical Methods in Developing Prospective Teachers to Measure the Mental States of the Students, J Res Med Dent Sci, 2021, 9 (5):93-92.
Received: 28-Apr-2021 Accepted: 13-May-2021 Published: 20-May-2021